Slurry Valve Selection for Difficult Mediums
A few mediums in particular, such as abrasive or scaling mediums, can create operational problems for certain types of valves. It is paramount to think carefully about our slurry valve selection to ensure optimal valve operation.
Which mediums hamper valve operation?
Abrasive, corrosive and scaling mediums may hamper certain types of valves. Other kinds of mediums and slurries can create operational problems for the valves as well. Because it would be impossible to cover all existing mediums and slurries, we will focus on above mentioned.
How can abrasive or corrosive slurry harm valves?
Certain types of valves can be harmed by either abrasive or scaling slurries.
- The reason lies in pockets or cavities in the valve structure that allow for material accumulation and hardening in these areas.
- Another factor that has a negative impact on valves is the use of reduced port valves which restrict flow and increase velocity.
- Increased velocity of highly abrasive slurries often leads to abrasive wear on exposed metal or hardened surfaces.
Any valve that has structures in the flow stream is not ideal for extremely abrasive flow streams. Good example is a butterfly valve that has a disc directly in the middle or slightly offset from the middle.
Correct slurry valve selection for abrasive, corrosive or scaling slurries
When looking for the right valve for these mediums, start with the following:
- All on-off open-closed valves should be full port design unless for flow control applications.
- Valve design should minimize void or pockets that allow for material accumulation and operational problems later.
- The valve should be self-cleaning.
- Materials of construction should withstand both abrasive and corrosive mediums.
- Manual screw assemblies should be sealed to prevent material accumulation.
Pinch valve: ideal for abrasive slurry
Good slurry valve selection for processes which include abrasive, corrosive and scaling slurries is a high-quality pinch valve. The reason pinch valves are ideal is that they are one of the only self-cleaning valves. The rubber sleeve inside the valve body is simply an extension of the pipeline when the valve is in the open position. In most designs, the rubber sleeve is full port and creates no velocity or restrictions.
Where the pinch valve really shines is that the valve is self-cleaning in scaling substances. When the valve begins to close, the rubber stretches. This stretching helps to start to flake the scaled-on layer. As the valve continues to close, the velocities increase across the sleeve’s elastic sealing surface and help to clear any remaining scale. Since the sleeve has a very smooth inner surface, there is no chance for material to accumulate in pockets or cavities. Simply put, pockets or cavities are nonexistent in pinch valves.
Figure 1: The heart of the pinch valve is the rubber sleeve. Rubber can vary tremendously in quality, so be careful when selecting pinch valves.
Lime slurry particles can settle in valve’s cavities
One example of a medium that causes problems for valves and instrumentation is lime slurry or often called milk of lime. The reason lime slurry is difficult is that it is both abrasive and has the tendency to scale within pipelines. When mixed with water, lime does not dissolve in solution but rather is a suspended solid.
Often, pipelines with lime slurry are designed with a re-circulation loop. The lime slurry can then stay in continuous motion to minimize lime particle settling. Even with continuous circulation, lime particles can still settle in void pockets and cavities. For instance, with a ball valve, the valve has an area surrounding the outside of the ball in the valve that fills with material and causes continually rising torque on the valve. Plug valves also have an area around the plug that becomes compacted with material.
Sometimes, ball and plug valves may utilize body cavity fillers, but regardless, the problem still exists where scale builds up on the ball or plug of the valves, causing more difficult operation and often destroys the seats within the valves. Particularly with flow control valves, life of the valves may be severely reduced. In certain cases, the mean time between failure (MTBF) may be only three to six months.
Other difficult slurries for valves
Other mediums that often cause shorter than optimal valve life are: silica dioxides, sodium silicates, titanium dioxide, precipitated calcium carbonate, toothpaste, clays, mining slurries, green liquor, black liquor, bottom ash, fly ash, gypsum and alumina catalysts, to name a few (See Figure 2). Almost any mineral-based slurry can be a problem for many types of valves. All of these mediums will often foul standard valves.
Another issue for many valves is almost anything that is pneumatically conveyed or moved through a dense phase system. Even something as simple as baby powder would be thought to be smooth and easy, but when pneumatically conveyed, the abrasive effects on valves can be devastating. Some very difficult pneumatically conveyed materials are carbon black, cement, fly ash, titanium coke and ore.
Figure 2. Pinch valves used at a coal-burning power plant in New York. The valves are ANSI 300 lbs. automatic isolation valves with solenoids and limit switches isolating high-pressure bottom ash up to 300 psig. The average sleeve lifetime in high-pressure bottom ash in this plant is more than five years. The plant has 74 high-pressure pinch valves in this application.
Corrosive mediums are best handled by pinch valves
Corrosive mediums may cause significant materials-of-construction requirements for many valves. Of course, materials of construction must be capable to withstand or minimize corrosive mediums. For instance, ball valves, plug valves, diaphragm valves, knife gate valves and butterfly valves all need wetted parts to be able to withstand the corrosive medium. In most cases, depending on the medium, the body material and internal balls, plugs, gates or discs may need to be manufactured out of exotic alloys. Some common alloys would be Monel, Hastelloy, titanium or super-duplex materials. This can increase lead times, and the cost may escalate five to 10 times the standard cost of one of these valves.
With pinch valves in corrosive mediums, there can be many different rubber sleeve materials that can resist corrosive destruction. The rubber sleeve is the only component of the valve that contacts the medium. So, 100% of the remaining valve structure is isolated from the corrosive medium. Examples of different rubber compounds and recommended types of service are shown in Table 1.
Table 1. General guidelines for rubber compounds and types of service. *Always consult with the manufacturer for their recommendation.
Control valves in abrasive mediums
There are many ways to attack abrasive mediums. With control valves, the situation is further exasperated. Control valves are rarely full port. The port diameter is sized for the proper flow rate, inlet pressure and delta P. When sizing control valves, cavitation and high velocity are enemies of the valve and downstream piping. Sizing is done to minimize the damaging effects.
Figure 3. 24-inch control pinch valves delivered to a Western Canada mining operation for flotation cell control. The valves are controlled via a 4-20 mA electropneumatic positioner.
How to improve valve’s durability?
With abrasive substances, slurry valve selection must be careful while keeping in mind special care of materials. You should select a valve that controls the flow accurately and can withstand the abrasive medium. There are two routes to take to improve valve survivability.
- One is to make internals harder with materials such as Stellite, TMT5, ceramics or others.
- The other route is to go softer. Rubber lining has been used successfully for years, and the jagged abrasive particles bounce off the elastic surface without damaging the surface.
With coated metallic or ceramic valves, the repair, when needed, is costly. The internals for a 3-inch ceramic valve may cost from $8,000 to $10,000. Coated metallic valves may require extensive rebuilding of the material lost through abrasion and then recoating with hard coatings. This work cannot be done at a plant site and leads to extensive lead times and costly repairs.
Pinch valve rubber sleeve is the only wear part
With pinch valves, the elastic rubber sleeve can be replaced quickly and cost effectively, usually in less than one hour. The repair cost of repairing a pinch control valve is usually a fraction of repairing a ceramic or hardened metal valve.
Select slurry valves based on individual applications
All too often, process plants of various types try to use standard valves in abrasive mediums. The result is often less than desirable, and repairs are frequent and costly. The desire for standardization of certain types of valves is admirable and makes tremendous sense for many sites. But it just does not work in every single application. There are certain types of valves that perform very well in certain conditions such as highly corrosive or highly abrasive mediums. Carefully consider the slurry valve selection because it can bring significant cost savings in the long run. A valve that may need to be replaced every three to six months can be improved to years before repairs need to be done.
It is also important to note that all valves are not created equally. One manufacturer’s quality can vary greatly from another. A ball valve, for instance, has a body, typically a stainless-steel ball and some form of Teflon or other seats. The quality of a ball valve can vary, but ball valves in general have a similar quality.
With pinch valves, the heart of the valve is the rubber sleeve. Rubber can vary tremendously in quality, so be careful when selecting pinch valves. Also, if you have tried a pinch valve with less than optimal performance, then perhaps you just chose the wrong manufacturer. If you face a nagging control valve or on/off valve issue in an abrasive or corrosive medium, you might want to give a high-quality pinch valve a try. (See Figure 1.)
Todd Loudin, President, Flowrox North America